Post image for Cracks in the Armor

In a fight we didn’t invite, dog fanciers have made a few errors in judgment that we’re now acknowledging. Chief among them has been a failure to effectively communicate to the general public who we are, and why dedicated breeders are the best hope for the future of sound canine companions. Early on, too many among us miscalculated the threat posed by a well-funded, well-organized animal rights machine, and when the “adopt-don’t-shop movement” spun off into a life of its own, we assumed in our innocence that its proponents couldn’t possibly mean us when referring to bad breeders. We failed to realize at the time that for these people, there is no such thing as a “good breeder.” Figuratively speaking, we woke up one day to find that ”rescue” had become a new breed of dog, and “breeder” was a new dirty word. adopt don't shop,anti breeder,westminster kennel club dog show

As attitudes go, the fancy at least has consensus in how it perceives the threat. Whatever orbit any of us occupies in the dog fancy sphere, we are in agreement that adopt-don’t-shop proponents want to end all dog breeding, and the animal rights agenda is determined to end dog ownership altogether.

Less cohesive is how fanciers have gone about challenging the mischaracterization of our sport. There’s been no “clarion call to action,” no scheme to galvanize fanciers to come together to undo the damage that’s been done. We are an independent lot, we dog people, and it’s not always a trait that serves us well. Presently, there are hundreds of Facebook pages, websites and e-mail lists working to “take back the conversation,” but they’re acting independent of each other and without a “unifying call to action,” the message becomes diluted. We are, however, learning.

Public response, meanwhile, has been fractured, if not schizophrenic. A rescue dog at the end of the leash has empowered many individuals to assume an air of moral superiority. Others purchase their dog from a breeder, then lie about the dog’s origins rather than deal with the fallout from friends persuaded by the “overpopulation” myth. All the while, the public can’t seem to get enough of purebred dogs as evidenced by the burgeoning popularity of “Meet the Breeds” venues wherever they’re held. It’s puzzling. Are purebred dogs bad, or aren’t they? If the only acceptable purebred dog is a rescue, and hobby breeding is eventually legislated out of existence, one has to wonder where the public thinks future generations of the dogs they flock to see will come from.

Assumptions are made at our peril, and this writer has been as guilty as anyone by supposing that all the mistakes made in this battle have been ours alone. As it turns out, the rescue movement is not immune to basic human nature, and I see hairline cracks in their armor.

Much of the adopt-don’t-shop crusade began with individuals in lockstep about the scourge of “overpopulation,” “the evil of breeders,” and the notion that by adopting a dog rather than buying it, the first two problems would go away. It seems to me, however that the rescue world is steadily fracturing into splinter groups, philosophical differences of opinion between them. Everything about it reminds me of the feminist marches of the 1970s when women burned bras, demanded social liberation and equal pay for equal work, and respect for individual choices. Forty years later, those same women are now in their sixties, and as some of them see it, the movement morphed into something different from where it began. Not everyone from the early days embraces the 2016 version.

Something similar seems to be happening in the rescue world, and if we know where to look, we can connect the dots. Rabid rescue proponents have sucked the oxygen out of the room, but there are reasonable people still engaged in rescue who work independent of breed clubs. If perception is reality, the “rogue” actions of some rescues have besmirched the reputation of all of them; an ugly, on-going legal battle between an owner and a rescue operation in the mid-west hasn’t helped. Incidences of bites by damaged, and poorly placed rescue dogs are growing. Rumors of rescues breeding their own “rescue dogs,” are rampant, and at least one independent non-profit has compiled data that punches holes in alarming “overpopulation” numbers long cited by adoption-only proponents as their “raison de vivre.” Statistics collected by the same organization show that a mere fraction of shelter dogs are purebreds, and that dedicated fanciers are not the source for every one of them.

If more evidence was needed to hint at fissures growing in the rescue movement, it came at the New York Pet Fashion show. The adopt,rescue,purebred dog, westminster kennel club dog show,breederfashion show is always held during the week of Westminster in a host hotel for the dog show, and for years, I assumed that its attendees are “sympatico” with the dog fancy. I quickly learned otherwise when I finally visited the most recent show and spotted an “Adopt Don’t Shop” t-shirt sold at a booth. As I stared at the shirt, a scowl I didn’t realize I had on my face invited the booth owner to start a conversation that quickly turned contentious. We parried back and forth for ten minutes before we heard what the other was actually saying: She supported good breeders. I’ve been involved in rescue. She thought the fashion show made Rescue look ridiculous. I’ve put socks and shirts on my dogs.

This rescue advocate worked hard to form relationships with heritage breeders who occasionally helped her with puppy placements, and she respected their dedication. The t-shirt she was selling, however, is shorthand for, “no such thing as a good breeder” an insult to quality breeders. She knew how she regards good breeders, but hawking the shirt was a failure to effectively communicate to the purebred dog owning community, if not the general public and her own peers, that not all rescues vilify dedicated breeders.

Our opponents in this debate are exposing vulnerabilities. Reasonable people are reevaluating their associations within the rescue world. There are gaps in the media, and they present opportunities for us to share our success stories against the backdrop of greedy, hypocritical, and possibly felonious rescue operations. “Do-overs” don’t come around very around. Let’s get busy.

This piece first appeared in Dogs in Review, May 2016 under the title, Addressing the Adopt Don’t Shop Lobby

{ 17 comments }

Making Ourselves Relevant to the People We Need

January 18, 2016

It may have started with the Baby Boomers, but it is a rare generation these days that isn’t somewhat narcissistic in its youth. Most young adults get over themselves as they get older, but the challenge facing dog fanciers is how to reach these potential fanciers while they’re still young. There are six living generations […]

Read the full article →

Now in the Rearview Mirror: Eukanuba 2015

December 16, 2015
Thumbnail image for Now in the Rearview Mirror: Eukanuba 2015

Don’t it always seem to go/ That you don’t know what you’ve got/ ‘Til it’s gone From “Big Yellow Taxi” by Joni Mitchell The 2015 Eukanuba National Championship is now in the rearview mirror, and Joni Mitchell’s epic “Big Yellow Taxi”  (in which we don’t always appreciate what we’ve got until it’s gone)  reminds me […]

Read the full article →

Wow! You have a Great Face for Radio!

December 10, 2015

The conclusion that I have a great face for radio is something I came to determine on my own after having worked with a phone app named, “Periscope.”  What can you do. Aging comes to us all, and in the dog game, a weathered face should be regarded as evidence that the wearer has earned his […]

Read the full article →

Does This Bring You Joy?

November 12, 2015
Thumbnail image for Does This Bring You Joy?

When I learned that a competitor from the group ring recently won her breed’s National Specialty, I was hardly surprised. In my view, her dog is the complete package: Sound, exemplary of breed type, showy – and a moving fool. That said, a National Specialty draws out many great dogs, and presumably, such was the […]

Read the full article →

Performance Anxiety in the Ring: The Great Equalizer

September 16, 2015

The Best in Show ring had seven marvelous dogs handled by seven experienced handlers, but one, a friend, was in trouble.  She was uncharacteristically sweaty and grim-faced, and her intensity was throwing her off her game. This was a new and unexpected look for a person who had as many Best in Show rosettes at […]

Read the full article →

It’s Not About the Donald

August 30, 2015
Thumbnail image for It’s Not About the Donald

I don’t know if Donald Trump is the solution to this country’s problems, or if he’ll even win his party’s nomination, but whether he is the solution or isn’t, wins the nomination or doesn’t, neither is my point, anyway. At this moment in time, Trump’s unexpected success is revealing something about the electorate, and trying […]

Read the full article →

The “Better Than Average Effect”

July 29, 2015
Thumbnail image for The “Better Than Average Effect”

It’s maddening to know someone who refuses to change their mind about an issue even when presented with evidence proving them wrong. Social psychologists call this “cognitive dissonance,” and as infuriating as it is for the rest of us, being wrong is so psychically uncomfortable for these people that they’ll avoid any situation that heightens […]

Read the full article →

The Times They Are a Changin’

June 4, 2015
Thumbnail image for The Times They Are a Changin’

A Pew Research Center recently released the results of a study that are startling when looked at backwards. The percentage of single people who are American-born between 1971 and 1985 has gone from 16% to 46% in one generation. To rephrase: The number of 30-to-44-year olds who are single will have nearly tripled in just […]

Read the full article →